#instagramfail – A Billion Dollar Blunder?

For those of you who have not heard and are interested – Instagram instituted a new policy recently and the twitter world has blown up with #instagramfail.

#instagramfail

#instagramfail

It seems that people are pissed that Instagram (recently acquired by Facebook for 1 Billion Dollars!) announced that “according to their terms of service” anyone who has posted their pictures on the site agree that Instagram can use those photos in any sort of advertisement they see fit and the person who posted those photos will get nothing in return.

The best article I have seen so far on the subject is posted on Wired and was written by Mat Honan.

Mat’s thoughts are very succinct and to the point.  Check it out

In the few hours since everything “blew up in instagrams face” Facebook has released an announcement “clarifying the terms” of the “new agreement”, but it seems that thousands are fleeing the site and deleting their accounts according to the NY Times.

—

I have to agree with Mat Honan where in his article on Wired.com he said that while he agrees that Instagram (and Facebook by default) has every right to try and make some money from the site – the way they went about it is all wrong.

A Better Idea

I have a better idea.  Why not try some profit sharing?  That’s what Seth Godin has been doing with Squidoo for years.

Here’s more about Seth.

Can you imagine Instagram coming out with an announcement that they will now participate in profit sharing with all of those people who’s pictures they use and make money from will get “a cut” of the action?

An Incredible Idea

A good idea has now become even better!  If Instagram let the world know that all people had to do was post some pictures on their site and there was the “potential” for them (those who post pictures) to make money from it they would have to double their server capacity within a month – and then double it again.

#instagramfail

Who are the bonehead Harvard Graduates who thought they could get away with this sort of thing? 

A message goes out to all users saying :

  • To help us deliver interesting paid or sponsored content or promotions, you agree that a business or other entity may pay us to display your username, likeness, photos (along with any associated metadata), and/or actions you take, in connection with paid or sponsored content or promotions, without any compensation to you. (emphasis mine – JF)

I’ll refer you back to Mat Honan’s article on Wired.com.  He said it best.

Update

Maybe it was the fact that National Geographic turns off Instagram over new terms that Instagram has backpedaled and apologized to users.

This is all very interesting – stay tuned…

And Good Luck Out There,

Jack Folsgood